Mediawatch-UK

Friday, 1 June 2012

How the media affects us all


Earlier this week the All Party Parliamentary Group on body image published the results of its inquiry, Reflections on Body Image. 

Many commentators expressed surprise at the existence of such a group but its report (which you can access here) made compelling reading. 

The inquiry heard that more than half of the public has a negative body image and that body dissatisfaction in the UK was on the rise.  Girls as young as five are worrying about how they look and cosmetic surgery rates have increased by nearly 20% in the past four years.

According to the group’s report, pressure to achieve an unrealistic body ideal is now an underlying cause of serious health and relationship problems, damaging society by wreaking havoc with self esteem and affecting progress at school and work. 

The inquiry concluded that unrealistic media images were largely to blame finding that a toxic combination of the media, advertising and celebrity culture amount for almost three-quarters of the influence on body image in society.

The chair of the APPG, Jo Swinson MP, told the BBC’s Today programme that "it's something which has existed for a long time... but in terms of the scale of it, that is what is new, and it is being driven by the proliferation of media imagery portraying a so-called 'perfected ideal' that is entirely unattainable for the vast majority of people,"

Speaking at the launch of the report the CEO of Central YMCA said: "It's clear there's something seriously wrong in society when children as a young as five are worrying about their appearance, based on the messages they are seeing all around them.”

The report made a series of recommendations which include:
  • A requirement for advertisers to run long-term campaigns that reflect consumer desire for "authenticity and diversity"
  • A review of  broadcast and editorial guidelines on reporting on body-image issues
  • The creation of a new set of regulations controlling cosmetic surgery advertising
We have long held that the media we consume affects our attitudes, outlook and behaviour for good or for ill.  This report bears that out and shows how tragic the consequences can be; one in three men would sacrifice a year of life to achieve their ideal body.

Neither is this influence related solely to body image.  Highly sexual media imagery, which is almost impossible to avoid, is leading to a generation of prematurely sexualised children; forced to grow up too soon and being led to believe that their value comes only from their sexual appeal or activities and behaving accordingly.  Similarly media which portrays violence as normal and ignores the humanity of victims is leading to an increased acceptance of violence in our society.

The measures recommended in this report are welcome but they must be seen as part of the ‘bigger picture’.  As a society we are shaped by the media which surrounds us; it is time for a wider debate about whether we are happy with the direction in which this has led us.

Friday, 25 May 2012

How pornography impacts children



This week I attended an excellent conference in parliament which examined the effect of pornography on the adolescent brain.

Biopsychologist Dr William Struthers presented the latest research on brain development and outlined how early exposure to sexually explicit material affects development, attitudes and behaviour.

We learned that the arousal and reward areas of the brain develop before the area which governs context which means that early exposure to pornography exploits the developmentally compromised brain.

It is, quite literally, a violation of the childhood mind.

It is also a violation of the concept of consent; for over 80% of young people their first exposure to pornography is unintentional and memories of these first exposures are usually vivid and typically have negative emotional associations. 

Children’s access to pornography is, in effect, an on-going experiment.  However, the latest research shows that the greater the exposure to sexually explicit material the greater likelihood of developing poor self confidence, depression, social isolation and maladjustment and decreased bonding with parents and caregivers.

It is quite clear that the huge benefits of the technological revolution have come at a cost.  We have to find a solution in order to protect generations to come.

This week Google’s head of UK public policy has rejected the proposals to block porn as default unless specifically requested by adults.  She said the answer was greater education for parents.

She is quite right that there is clearly a great need to inform parents how harmful some internet content can be and to show them how best to protect their children.  However, Ofcom’s research shows us that almost half of parents do not currently use a filter for websites which means that millions of children remain at risk from potentially harmful online content.  We must act now in order to protect them.

Google makes a huge amount of money from online pornography – their head of public policy said that she had ‘no idea’ exactly how much  - so it is hardly surprising that they should resist measures to restrict access to it.

Why should the internet industry uniquely rest outside regulation?  Protecting children must be our first priority.

Vivienne Pattison, Director

Friday, 18 May 2012

Protecting children online


In 2004, the UK's mobile operators, under the auspices of the Mobile Broadband Group, published a code of practice about how to offer a safe browsing experience for children.   The result was that filters were automatically put on all pay-as-you-go handsets, regardless of the age of the user. In order to remove the filters, users needed either to ring up customer services or go into a mobile shop with proof of age.

At that time, few children accessed the internet via mobiles; today however, one in five children now own smartphones.

This responsible and far-sighted measure has helped to protect many children from potentially harmful content.   However, it was attacked this week by the Open Rights Group which published a report in which it found that 60 websites, including political commentaries and personal blogs, were incorrectly blocked by mobile filters designed to prevent children viewing adult content.

The group said the filters were ‘censoring’ normal web content.

In response the Mobile Broadband Group, denied this.  The group’s chairman said: "Even allowing for the ORG missing a few, 60 misclassified websites does not amount to anything that could reasonably be described as 'censorship', particularly when mobile operators are happy to remove the filters when customers show they are over 18 and will re-classify websites when misclassifications are pointed out to them….  this is how the small handful of websites that get referred to mobile operators each year are already dealt with".

Referencing their research the Open Rights Group has called on the government to reject automatic network filtering and instead give parents the option of whether they want such filters turned on.

The group claims that default block can have ‘harmful’ consequences for everyone.  We would argue that the consequences of children accessing adult material are far more harmful linked as they are to an increased risk of depression, self-esteem and identity disorders, premature sexual activity, sexually transmitted diseases, reduced educational attainment and success, constrained and stereotypical ideas about gender roles and negative consequences for cognitive, physical and psychological health.

There is no magic bullet; no filter system will be 100% effective and 100% error free but we believe that blocking adult material as a default measure remains the best way to protect children from harmful content.

The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, to which the UK is a signatory, states that ‘In all actions concerning children, whether undertaken by public or private social welfare institutions, courts of law, administrative authorities or legislative bodies, the best interests of the child shall be a primary consideration.’

The rights of children to a safe and healthy media environment must be taken seriously.


NB: If you are a parent it’s worth noting that this only applies to pay-as-you go phones; with contract phones users have to ask for filters to be installed.  This should always be done as a matter or course because the automatic filters installed on phones can be got around by using a wi-fi connection to access the internet rather than the phone specific 3G signal.

Friday, 11 May 2012

Children's rights are just as important as those of big business


Last week the High Court ruled that Internet Service Providers must block access to the file-sharing website The Pirate Bay. 

ISPs had previously resisted calls to block the site but following this ruling they have said that they will comply.

This move shows that it is technically possible to block websites at ISP level which means it must also be possible to put in place measures to combat the harmful effect of online porn on children.

However, the block has only come about because of an expensive court case brought by the British Phonographic Industry.  Big businesses can afford to enforce their rights through the courts but parents and children do not have this option.

Which powerful corporations are fighting to protect the interests of the victims of the ‘free and open’ internet that enables children to have pornography streamed into their bedrooms?

These are the interests which need real protection.  Children’s rights are just as important as those of big business and it is time for industry which makes more that £3 billion a year from selling internet access to take part of the responsibility for protecting children online.  If the industry will not do this then the Government must legislate; our children deserve adequate protection.

No further details of the promised consultation into protecting children from harmful online material have emerged this week.  As soon as they do, we will let you know.

Friday, 4 May 2012

Protecting children online tops the political agenda


 

Excellent news emerged from Downing Street this morning; the government is to begin a consultation into the best way to protect children from harmful online material.

The consultation will look at whether to introduce automatic filters, which would see porn blocked as a default unless users specifically opt-in to access it.  Also under discussion will be the less stringent ‘active choice’ which would mean users had to make a decision whether or not to activate controls when a new device or internet connection was purchased. 

This is a significant step in the right direction but it is important that we are not left with a compromise which fails to adequately protect children.  A default block on adult websites remains the clearest and most effective way of protecting children from harmful online content. 

The UK has led the world in tackling online child abuse with the creation of The Internet Watch Foundation and the Child Exploitation and Online Protection Centre.  This is another opportunity for the country to show the world how seriously the UK takes the protection of children online.

As soon as we have further details of the consultation we will update you so that you can have your say on this vital issue.

Further positive news emerged from Brussels today.  In a draft series of proposals put forward to make the internet a safer place for children, an age-based authentication system that limits where children can visit online is suggested.  In the draft proposal the European Commission warns that neglecting protections for children could have a ‘profound impact’ on European societies.  More details of the proposed scheme are due for publication on 30th May, as ever we will keep you updated.

Friday, 27 April 2012

Since when were the civil liberties of porn users more important than those of children?






Last week’s report from the Parliamentary Inquiry into Online Child Protection has continued to dominate headlines this week.  The Mail and The Sun have supported the proposal to block online pornography as a default unless users specifically opt in but, predictably, the industry has not been supportive.


An executive from Google has attacked the proposal saying that parents are to blame if their children access pornography.  The Internet Service Providers Association said the opt-in proposal would impact freedom of speech and disingenuously Jim Killock of the Open Rights Group told BBC Breakfast that the measures proposed would make the internet a more dangerous place for children.

We don’t accept these arguments from any other kind of media where industry, government and consumers work together for the benefit of all.  Television has a watershed, films are age rated and satellite broadcasters must put adult material behind a pin-code protection system.

This is merely scaremongering from an industry which makes in excess of £3 billion a year from selling internet access services.  The industry needs to take some of the responsibility of keeping children safe online.  The technology to do this exists; schools already have sophisticated filters in place and one ISP now offers them as an option.

As one commentator wrote earlier this week ‘since when were the civil liberties of porn users more important than those of children?’

Friday, 20 April 2012

Children need protection from online porn



This week the Parliamentary Inquiry into Online Child Protection, to which we are delighted to have submitted evidence, reported its recommendations.  The cross-party group found that many children are easily accessing online pornography and this exposure is having a negative effect on them.  It concluded that Internet Service Providers and the Government need to do more to keep children safe online.

The group recommended a number of measures, including a call for a formal consultation on the institution of an opt-in filter which would mean that online adult and material is blocked at source as a default.

The Inquiry also recommended that public Wi-Fi access provision should have a default adult content bar and that single account network filters for domestic broadband customers that could provide one-click filtering for all devices connected to a home internet connection should be rolled out within 12 months.

The inquiry said that, whilst government regulation of the internet should “always be done with the lightest touch”, it should prepare backstop powers to intervene if the internet industry fails to do enough.

Responding to the report during Prime Minister’s Question Time David Cameron said: “As a parent and as a politician, I am keen that we should help to protect people from such material.”  He said that he had “got together” some companies to “look at offering a choice of blocking all adult and age-restricted content on their home internet”.

At the launch of this report it was stated that the ‘active-choice’ system, which will be rolled out in October and require all new internet customers to make a decision on whether or not they wish to activate filters, was unlikely to provide widespread protection across the UK until the end of this decade by which time a further generation of children will have been exposed to degrading and damaging material.  Speaking at the launch campaigner Miranda Suit pointed out that that no one knows the full extent of the harm this will cause children, “they are guinea pigs” she said.

Time is of the essence.  The conclusions of the report are already making waves around Westminster and the Internet industry.  It is vital that the measures recommended are instituted quickly to protect the next generation.  In the two years since Claire Perry’s debate calling for opt-in protection millions more children have been exposed to corrosive and damaging material online.  We cannot allow millions more to fall victim to this social experiment.

You can access the full report here.